When is an accounting error material?
/The materiality of an accounting error is based on whether it impacts the economic decisions of the users of an entity’s financial statements. Thus, if the error is sufficiently significant that it will mislead lenders, investors, creditors, and other financial statement users, then it is considered to be material.
It can be difficult to decide whether an accounting error is material, since it is hard to determine whether it will impact user decisions. Contributing factors to consider when reaching this conclusion can be divided into qualitative and quantitative factors, as follows:
Qualitative factors. These are non-numeric, including errors that would trigger a debt covenant, alter the trend of a performance trend line, or notably impact a business ratio. In effect, these factors trigger decision points that are monitored by financial statement users.
Quantitative factors. These are numeric, including the reported revenue, gross margin, or net profit level.
Related AccountingTools Course
Examples of Material Accounting Errors
Here are three examples of when an accounting error is material:
Revenue overstatement. If a company mistakenly records $5 million as revenue instead of the correct amount of $500,000, this overstatement can mislead investors about the company’s performance, potentially influencing decisions about buying, selling, or holding shares. Such an error is material if it significantly impacts the company’s reported profitability and financial ratios.
Omission of a significant liability. Suppose a company fails to record a $2 million lawsuit liability that is likely and estimable. This omission could present a misleading picture of the company’s financial health and liquidity, affecting creditors' decisions regarding loan approvals or interest rates.
Inventory misstatement. If a manufacturing company’s inventory is overstated by $1 million due to a clerical error, it can inflate both assets and net income. This could mislead management and investors about the company’s efficiency and profitability, making the error material, especially if inventory is a substantial part of the company's assets.
In each of these examples, the materiality depends on the size and nature of the error relative to the financial statements as a whole.